OXO On Barista Brain Vs Bonavita

There are a multitude of different coffee makers out there.

You can find Keurigs for single-serving preferences, Nespresso for espresso and many others for a higher-end drip style coffee.

Among these are the OXO On Barista and Bonavita models.

These are two very popular options, which provide delicious coffee at an affordable price.

To help you with determining which is the ideal choice for you, we’re going to take a close look into these two devices.

Read on and learn what they can do for you!

OXO On Barista


This compact little device is great for getting a truly delicious brew.

The OXO On Barista allows you to brew anywhere from two to 9 cups, perfect for making your own or sharing.

It also uses a shower head with a rainmaker design to ensure all of the grounds are well-saturated.

There’s also an LED interface that makes using the device and seeing the time much easier.

Furthermore, this is also a user-friendly design, using a single dial to make your selections.

There’s even a timer to help you wake up to a hot cup of coffee!

To ensure that your coffee is the perfect temperature, the OXO is set to brew between 197.6 and 204.8 degrees.

Consequently, you’ll be able to trust that your grounds are well-saturated without risking a burnt flavor.

For those who like single-serve machines, this one also provides that ability.

That way, you won’t always have to be making multiple servings when you just need one cup for yourself.

Some users have also found that this device makes some of the best coffee they’ve ever had.

It’s definitely a coffee maker that is well worth the taste!


  • Intuitive controls
  • Sturdy design
  • Generates the perfect brewing temperature
  • Easy to clean
  • Runs quietly


  • Buttons can sometimes get stuck
  • Some features can cease working
  • Can arrive in nonworking condition


There are many who praise this coffee maker for the sturdy design it provides.

In addition, the controls are intuitive and easy to use and it’s set to brew at the perfect temperature.

Many users also appreciate that it runs rather quietly, avoiding waking anyone up in the morning.

That said, there can be some issues that can occur with this device.

Some can find that the buttons on it may get stuck too easily.

Meanhwile, others can find that it simply ceases working altogether.

If you notice any of these issues, make sure to contact customer service as soon as you can.

Bonavita (BV1900TD)


For the sake of this comparison, we’re going to take a look into the BV1900TD.

This model allows you to brew up to 8 cups at a time and offers the convenience of a digital display.

It also provides a timer that allows you to set the machine to begin brewing as soon as you wake up in the morning with minimal effort.

To keep your coffee at the perfect temperature, it also brews in the 195 to 205 degree range.

You can also use a pre-infusion mode for added flavor and benefits so that you can get the most from your cup.

To ensure for better saturation, this option also includes a filter basket with a flat bottom as well as a shower head with a larger size.

That way, you’ll get the best possible saturation, resulting in great overall flavor.

In addition, the included stainless steel carafe works to keep your brew hotter for longer than other models.

You’ll also be able to trust that all of the plastic parts are safe, as they are BPA-free.

That said, you can also opt for a glass carafe if that suits your preferences better.

Regardless, you’re sure to get some truly delicious coffee!


  • Affordable pricing
  • Great saturation
  • Delicious results
  • Brews quickly
  • Includes a thermal carafe


  • Thermal carafe complaints
  • The amount it can brew may become limited over time
  • Breakages can occur


What many consumers like about the Bonavita is that it comes at an affordable price.

Furthermore, it provides delicious results and brews rather quickly, so you won’t need to wait too long for your brew.

On top of that, the thermal carafe can do a great job of keeping your coffee hot.

However, keep in mind that some users tend to prefer the glass carafe, stating that the stainless steel carafe doesn’t keep their brew very hot.

Some can also find that breakages can occur, including limiting the brew amount over time.

You will want to make sure you de-scale it regularly.



Just by looking at these two devices, they appear rather similar.

However, there are plenty of differences that can help you to determine which is the best for you.

The first is that the Bonavita is able to brew 8 cups at a time, while the OXO is able to brew 9.

So if you want that extra cup, then the latter is the ideal option.

They both strive to brew at the right temperature, though they do differ very slightly in their ranges.

The Bonavita brews at between 195 and 205 degrees while the OXO brews between 197.6 and 204.8 degrees

Furthermore, both options also include a stainless steel carafe, designed for keeping your coffee hot.

Both also provide specialized shower heads that are made to ensure the best possible saturation.

In addition, you’ll be able to set a timer for either of these coffee makers to start themselves at a time of your choosing.

Overall, the OXO is the slightly more highly-rated of the two, but they come pretty close overall.

On either option, you may want to consider a glass carafe, as users can find that the stainless steel ones don’t keep their brew as hot as they had expected.


There is a pretty decent price difference between these two items.

If you’re looking for the coffee maker that is the most budget-friendly, the Bonavita BV1900TD is the least expensive of the two.

However, it’s worth considering the difference in the levels of value you might get from each.

While the OXO is more expensive, the reviews for it tend to be a little bit higher.

This may show that it’s able to provide a little more value if you’re willing to pay more for it.

Ultimately, it’s up to you which one is the most ideal!

Which Is Better?

Overall, these two devices are relatively similar.

However, according to customer reviews, the OXO may be able to provide a little more value.

That’s not to say that the Bonavita isn’t also a great device.

Many customers have used their coffee maker models and found it delivered them coffee more delicious than they’ve ever had before.

As a result, it may be tough to choose between the two!

Either one may also pair well with a travel mug, so you can take your delicious drink on the go.

You’ll also want a top-notch coffee to make your brew with!

For those who want the most delicious brew, it’s best to start with fresh beans that are well-stored.

After that, using a grinder will ensure you get the freshest results!

Using those tips and either of these machines, you’ll surely get some of the best cups of coffee you’ve ever had.

Brian Mounts

Head blogger, editor, and owner of "Top Off My Coffee", a website that has been educating readers about coffee brewing techniques and equipment since 2012.

Wait, Wait...There's More!